Best Renters Insurance Companies

Do you want to know about the best renters’ insurance companies? Then you are in the right place as we are here to offer you the best among the renters’ insurance companies. As we all know, our home is one of our most valuable properties. So, the protection that renters’ insurance provides when you rent your home out cannot be ignored.

Best Renters Insurance Companies

Renters’ insurance provides you with liability insurance to cover your belongings, and it comes at an inexpensive cost. Companies can also insure you against fire, theft, and other liabilities such as a dog biting a neighbor.

Research conducted by an Assurant survey said that 45 percent of the renters companies, despite the availability, do not offer renters’ insurance coverage. Depending on the location and other factors, the average renter’s premium for the insurance does range from $15 each month to $30 each month.

Although many of the renters go without it, the insurance from the renters’ company is what you can get to protect you whenever you want to rent out your apartment. When looking for the best renters’ insurance companies, we look at coverage standards, price, limits, and customer service.

Best Renters Insurance Companies

  • State Farm
  • American Family Insurance
  • MetLife
  • Nationwide
  • Erie Insurance
  • Liberty Mutual
  • Farmers
  • Toggle

State Farm

Renters’ insurance is available nationally from State Farm at competitive prices with flexible policy options. Discounts for purchasing multiple policies and setting up a home security system are both offered.

Due to its strong financial standing and capacity to pay claims, this insurer has received ratings of AA from S&P Global Ratings and A++ from AM Best. Renters’ insurance from State Farm offers loss-of-use coverage if a loss renders a property uninhabitable.

It also covers a wide range of losses. However, it does not cover harm to the actual property, water damage brought on by flooding, or harm from landslides, earthquakes, settling degradation, or animal activity. Additionally, you have the choice to purchase add-on protection, such as identity restoration and pet medical insurance.

American Family Insurance

Renters can get reasonable coverage from American Family Insurance that covers their personal property, medical expenses, liability, replacement fees for lost or stolen belongings, and hotel accommodations if a covered occurrence prevents them from staying in their rented house.

Pet health insurance, identity theft protection, and coverage for a home office or other home business space are all available as add-on coverage options. Renters’ insurance is available at reduced rates in a variety of ways, including multipolicy, smart home, and auto pay savings.

Renter’s insurance savings from bundling with your vehicle insurance might reach 15%, which is competitive with discounts from other companies. Another approach to saving money on renters’ insurance is to decrease your deductible coverage, provided you keep your policy in force.


Another well-known brand in the country that provides renters’ insurance is MetLife. The replacement or repair of property is covered by standard insurance, up to its real cash value. If you’d want to purchase extra protection for up to $15,000, you can insure specialty things like electronics, and sporting goods.

Renters’ insurance from MetLife is accessible in all 50 states. And most policies come with liability coverage ranging from $25,000 to $500,000. Certain companies and membership organizations provide discounts, which can help you save money on premiums.

Through savings for multiple policies, you can also save. MetLife provides customer service assistance every day of the week, including holidays. To learn about all the coverage options and to receive a thorough estimate, you must speak with a MetLife agent. Only for basic coverage are online rates available.


Nationwide offers basic renters’ insurance, which covers personal property, loss of use, personal liability, building expansions and changes, and unauthorized credit card purchases.

For personal items kept in a car, trailer, or boat, you may also add coverage for valuables and collectibles, earthquakes, water damage, and theft protection. Discounts are available if you have numerous nationwide insurance policies or if your house has safety features like smoke alarms or a burglar alarm system.

Keeping your insurance claim-free may also qualify you for a discount. The On Your Side Assessment, which lets you get a tailored review of your insurance to make sure you have the correct coverage and are taking advantage of all available discounts, is one additional benefit.

Erie Insurance

Renters in covered states may purchase personal property, liability, and living expense coverage from Erie Insurance. Erie Insurance provides coverage in fewer states (Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia, Wisconsin, and Washington, D.C.).

However, it does so with excellent customer service if you need to file a claim or have questions about your policy. When you combine policies with Erie, discounts are available.

There are more than 13,000 agents available to assist you. Most budgets can usually afford policies. To acquire a quote and talk about the coverage that is best for you, get in touch with an agent.

Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual is an insurance company that focuses on the process of keeping its promise. As part of this process, its website asks for incident data and photographs. Renters’ insurance is also available at reasonable prices, with discounts offered when you bundle coverage or wait five years between claims.

Standard policies include liability protection, personal property, medical payments, and supplementary living expenses. Additional insurance for personal property replacement fees, jewelry, or earthquake damage is available if you feel you need it.

The company offers quotes online and has operations in all 50 states. So, you can acquire coverage wherever you rent. It just takes five to ten minutes to start a claim using Liberty Mutual’s mobile app or website.

Best One-Stop Insurance Shopping: Farmers

According to J.D. Power, farmers score above average for claims satisfaction. The provider offers typical renters’ insurance plans with discounts for home security system installation and non-smoker status.

Personal responsibility, property, medical payments, identity theft, and additional living expenses are all included in the coverage. The renter’s insurance coverage can easily be combined with other insurance policies, such as auto, umbrella, and life.

If you have a covered loss, you can submit a claim online as well as request a quote. AM Best has assigned Farmers a B++ rating, indicating the company’s financial stability and operational capability.

If you need assistance filing a claim or have concerns about your policy, customer support is available seven days a week. Additionally, they claim help is offered around the clock.

ToggleRenters Insurance

With Toggle’s renters’ insurance, which protects you wherever you are, you may be protected against covered situations like losing your laptop in an airport or getting mugged while abroad.

Even coverage for your pets or identity theft is an option. Toggle will lower your deductible to save you money in the event of a claim for each year that you are covered and don’t submit a claim.

Toggle can assist in securing both your personal and commercial property if you own a business or side gig. There are three subscription levels for renter’s insurance policies: Basic, Standard, and Premium.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here